NMCC Banner
spacer1
spacer2
spacer3


New Mexico Court of Appeals – Unreported Memorandum Opinions – 2015
This page contains memorandum opinions of the New Mexico Court of Appeals that were not selected for publication in the New Mexico Reports. Please see Rule 12-405 NMRA for restrictions on the citation of unpublished decisions. Please also note that these electronic decisions may contain computer-generated errors or other deviations from the official paper version filed by the Supreme Court and will not include the filing date. The filing date for each decision can be found in the table below.

Sorting options — The decisions may be sorted by "Filing Date", "Short Title", or "Docket No."
Click on the column name/header — the decisions will sort in descending/ascending order.
Note that the Short Title column contains the full text of the decision in PDF format.

Filing DateShort TitleDocket No.
01/05/2015State v. Lujan33,995
01/06/2015Sinfuego v. Board of County Commissioners for Curry County33,998
01/07/2015Reyes v. Farmers Insurance33,435
01/08/2015State v. Pacheco34,089
01/12/2015Orduno v. Tierney34,019
01/12/2015Discover Bank v. Bawol34,022
01/12/2015Titus v. Titus33,999
01/12/2015Cain v. Bravo33,924
01/12/2015State v. Delao33,870
01/12/2015State v. Duran33,862
01/12/2015State v. Garcia33,796
01/12/2015Firstenberg v. City of Santa Fe33,441
01/12/2015State v. Kupfer33,199
01/13/2015Discover Bank v. Bawol34,021
01/14/2015State v. Melendez34,055
01/14/2015In the Matter of Minor Children34,030
01/14/2015Tinsley Trailer Park v. Cepeda33,864
01/14/2015State v. Venegas-Diaz33,106
01/15/2015State v. Medina33,805
01/15/2015State v. Valenzuela33,868
01/15/2015Corral v. NM Dep't of Workforce Solutions34,023
01/15/2015State v. Renteria-Lopez32,987
01/21/2015Shaner v. Shaner34,066
01/21/2015Bank of New York Mellon v. Singh34,041
01/21/2015State v. Dimas33,976
01/27/2015State v. Villanueva34,092
01/28/2015Johnson v. Madron32,668
01/28/2015State v. Romero34,162
01/29/2015McEaddy v. New Mexico State Agency for Surplus Property33,576
01/29/2015State v. Padilla33,887
01/29/2015State v. Ridley33,895
01/29/2015Lester v. Lester33,926
01/29/2015State v. Pierson33,898
01/29/2015City of Albuquerque v. One 1989 Chrysler33,261
01/29/2015State v. Elliot32,787
01/29/2015State v. Sutton33,643
02/02/2015Singh v. United States of America33,672; 33,968
02/04/2015Gabriel v. McGrath34,040
02/09/2015State v. Oropeza33,909
02/09/2015Arrellano v. New Mexico Department of Health34,062
02/09/2015State v. Hall33,953
02/10/2015N.E.A. of N.M. v. Cent. Consol. Sch. Dist.34,151
02/10/2015State v. McBride34,013
02/10/2015State v. Reyes33,728
02/10/2015Lopez v. Gonze33,354
02/11/2015State v. Ramos33,969
02/12/2015State v. Castro33,886
02/12/2015State v. Najar34,002
02/12/2015State v. Peralta33,987
02/16/2015State v. Cantu33,892
02/16/2015Behles Law Firm, P.C. v. Hudson Albuquerque, LLC33,897
02/16/2015State v. Lerke34,029
02/16/2015State v. Rockymore34,138
02/16/2015City of Las Cruces v. Fuller34,101
02/17/2015State v. Vuljevic33,860
02/17/2015Herrera v. Heritage Home Healthcare33,841
02/17/2015State v. Beckwith33,828
02/17/2015Romero v. ARCA33,662
02/17/2015State v. Albert33,083
02/18/2015State v. Felipe Avalos32,689
02/19/2015State v. Phillips33,879
02/19/2015Bissey v. Morris33,855
02/19/2015State v. Yanez33,954
02/19/2015State v. Garcia33,359
02/23/2015State v. Ortegon33,792
02/23/2015Alderete v. City of Albuquerque33,151; 33,380; 33,714
02/23/2015State v. Buschalla33,885
02/24/2015State v. Villegas34,149
02/24/2015State v. Dominguez34,121
02/25/2015State v. Foust34,060; 34,074
02/25/2015Vanderlugt v. Vanderlugt32,950
02/26/2015State v. Clayton34,179
03/03/2015State v. Izundu33,221
03/03/2015State v. Garcia33,794
03/03/2015State v. Gonzalez33,884
03/04/2015Padilla v. Bernalillo County Sheriff's Dep't34,084
03/04/2015State v. Garcia33,193
03/05/2015State v. Hunter33,663
03/05/2015State v. Bouldin34,214
03/05/2015State v. Campbell33,128
03/09/2015State v. Jimenez33,158
03/09/2015State v. Warner32,913
03/09/2015State v. Lydia A.32,877; 32,884
03/09/2015State v. Cuffee32,797
03/09/2015State v. Hobbs33,389
03/09/2015Hilgendorf v. Chen33,056
03/10/2015State v. Campbell33,695
03/10/2015State v. Reyes33,059
03/10/2015State v. Tohsonie33,157
03/11/2015State v. Davenport33,546
03/11/2015State v. Putnam34,213
03/11/2015State v. Rafael34,175
03/11/2015State v. Garza34,072
03/12/2015State v. Aldaco33,811
03/12/2015State v. Campbell33,693
03/12/2015State v. Shorty34,049
03/12/2015State v. Jones34,024
03/12/2015State v. Blackwater33,710
03/16/2015State v. Woodard34,009
03/16/2015State v. Martinez33,994
03/16/2015State v. Primrose34,087
03/16/2015Bourgoyne v. Bourgoyne33,916
03/16/2015Burke v. Jones33,824; 33,825; 33,826
03/16/2015State v. Rodriguez34,125
03/16/2015State v. Davidson32,795
03/16/2015State v. Trujillo33,581
03/17/2015Eichenberg v. Duran34,032
03/17/2015Garcia v. Lopez34,104
03/18/2015State v. Skaggs34,127
03/18/2015Enoah v. NM Human Svcs Dep't33,421
03/18/2015State v. Chico33,490
03/23/2015State v. Aldaco33,799
03/23/2015US Bank, NA v. Payne34,160
03/23/2015State v. Young33,751
03/24/2015Guzman v. Rimbert34,086
03/24/2015State v. Ornelas33,919
03/24/2015Rohrer v. Smith's Food & Drug33,175
03/25/2015State v. Koreh34,263
03/25/2015State v. Juarez34,154
03/25/2015State v. Padilla34,069
03/26/2015State v. Paul33,319
03/26/2015State v. Morgan34,187
04/01/2015State v. Deanna H.34,295
04/01/2015State v. Thompson34,137
04/02/2015Chip v. Chip33,958
04/02/2015State v. Gallion34,018
04/06/2015McWilliams v. Jensen33,137
04/06/2015State v. Slade34,128
04/07/2015State v. Doliber34,202
04/07/2015State v. Pacheco34,178
04/07/2015State v. Puente33,806
04/08/2015State v. Jones33,978
04/08/2015Vigil v. Bonanza Creek Ranch34,402
04/08/2015State v. Burke33,834
04/08/2015State v. Miller33,838
04/08/2015State v. Mike34,113
04/08/2015State v. Sanders34,158
04/08/2015State v. Leyba34,177
04/08/2015State v. Ortega34,203
04/08/2015State v. Yoingco34,304
04/09/2015State v. Norberto32,353
04/09/2015State v. Charlie32,504
04/13/2015Orduno v. Martinez33,948
04/13/2015Romero v. City of Albuquerque33,917
04/13/2015State v. Ortiz33,742
04/13/2015State v. Vallejos33,928
04/14/2015Khalsa v. Puri33,622
04/14/2015Sowards v. Biotronik34,373
04/14/2015Dukes v. Dukes33,844
04/16/2015State v. Renteria34,093
04/20/2015Marquez v. Herrera Sch. Buses34,142
04/20/2015City of Santa Fe v. Baca34,091
04/20/2015State v. Bersane34,094
04/20/2015State v. Maestas33,402
04/21/2015Montano v. Howes34,225
04/22/2015State v. Jake33,501
04/22/2015Gomez-Leon v. AT&T33,912
04/23/2015State v. Serna33,001
04/23/2015State v. Baca34,340
04/23/2015Meza v. Montes34,309
04/27/2015Wilson v. Davis34,333
04/27/2015Stone v. Smith32,814
04/27/2015State v. Lewis34,117
04/28/2015State v. Red Dawn Henderson34,377
04/28/2015State v. Martinez32,424
04/28/2015State v. Brown34,173
04/28/2015State v. Franklin34,057
04/29/2015State v. Garcia32,753
04/29/2015Deutsche Bank Nat'l Trust Co. v. Price32,869
04/29/2015In re Protest of Case Manager32,940
04/30/2015Janecka v. Janecka33,822
05/04/2015Gurule v. Albuquerque Public Schools34,169
05/05/2015State v. Jim34,130
05/05/2015State v. Lamb34,122
05/05/2015State v. Stevens34,080
05/05/2015Pollack v. Pollack34,453
05/05/2015Higarea v. Thatcher34,256
05/05/2015State v. Roberts33,285
05/06/2015Williams v. Harris34,239
05/07/2015State v. Granados33,972
05/07/2015State v. Tsosie34,351
05/07/2015Moya v. City of Albuquerque34,349
05/07/2015State v. Williams34,079
05/07/2015Loancare v. Harris33,648
05/11/2015State v. Evensen33,338
05/12/2015State v. Amaya34,186
05/12/2015State v. Enriquez34,145
05/12/2015State v. Mata34,153
05/12/2015State v. Medina34,163
05/12/2015State v. Cass34,176
05/13/2015Hernandez v. Ontiveros34,290
05/13/2015Armstrong v. Elkins34,434
05/13/2015In the Matter of the Estate of Harold Garrett34,368; 34,446
05/13/2015Gonzalez v. Jefferies34,449
05/13/2015Torrez v. Garrison33,735
05/13/2015Bank of New York Mellon Trust Co. v. Hampton33,780
05/13/2015State v. Dunn34,273
05/13/2015Franklin v. New Mexico Tax & Rev.34,324
05/13/2015Minghelli v. McPherson34,210
05/14/2015State v. Salazar34,205
05/14/2015State v. Tinoco34,317
05/18/2015State v. Jimenez34,016
05/18/2015Casa Bendera v. Am. Spectrum34,280
05/18/2015State v. Miller34,326
05/18/2015State v. Martinez34,268
05/18/2015State v. Coleman34,088
05/18/2015State v. Maez34,291
05/19/2015PNC Mortgage v. H. Khalsa34,172
05/19/2015State v. Martinez-Thorman33,119
05/19/2015State v. Ruiz34,168; 34,228
05/19/2015State v. Lopez32,773
05/19/2015State v. Garcia34,407
05/20/2015State v. Brown34,173
05/20/2015State v. Lopez34,323
05/20/2015Hone v. State34,248
05/20/2015BYZ Enter. v. Erven34,241
05/27/2015Ward v. Harvey33,888
05/27/2015Mendoza v. Huber33,913
05/27/2015State v. Lee34,070
05/27/2015State v. Morgan34,183
05/28/2015Doyle v. City of Albuquerque34,334
05/28/2015State v. Giraudo34,252
05/28/2015State v. Tafoya34,218
05/28/2015Wells Fargo Bank v. Dibble34,244
06/01/2015State v. Swartout34,044
06/01/2015State v. Vargas34,046
06/01/2015Hunter v. City of Las Cruces34,076
06/01/2015State v. Alderete34,222
06/01/2015Kruskal v. Melliger34,229
06/01/2015State v. Widmer33,679
06/02/2015Smith v. Moore34,433
06/02/2015State v. Swann34,408
06/02/2015Danemann v. Myrup34,378
06/03/2015State v. Lopez34,118
06/03/2015State v. Terin S.33,258
06/03/2015State v. Newman34,383
06/04/2015State v. Henderson34,307
06/04/2015Romero v. Hone34,217
06/04/2015In the Matter of the Russell Trust32,730; 32,629
06/04/2015State v. Jones34,267
06/08/2015State v. Vasquez29,868
06/09/2015State v. Lopez34,455
06/09/2015State v. Kuenstler33,640
06/09/2015State v. Oakes34,358
06/09/2015Montoya v. Colfax County34,372
06/09/2015Parrish v. City of Clovis33,996
06/10/2015Blanch v. Custom Plumbing33,918
06/11/2015Gateway Mortgage v. Bagley34,249
06/11/2015State v. Tinoco33,866
06/15/2015Haselby v. Richardson32,943
06/15/2015State v. Heredia32,937
06/16/2015Herbison v. Schwaner34,585
06/16/2015State v. Flores34,296
06/16/2015State v. Chavez34,155
06/17/2015Ketcheside v. Lovelace Rehab Hosp.33,454
06/17/2015Whatley v. Corizon Medicare D.O.C.34,403
06/17/2015State v. Wood34,604
06/18/2015State v. Belknap32,983
06/18/2015Kapnison v. Kapnison34,481
06/18/2015Washburn v. Goodman34,627
06/18/2015State v. Coronado32,435
06/18/2015Discover Bank v. MiMauro34,589
06/22/2015State v. Kevin R.34,059
06/23/2015Wells Fargo Bank v. Nagji34,078
06/23/2015Monteil v. Goslin34,397
06/23/2015State v. Irvin32,643
06/23/2015Saunders v. Rodriguez34,575
06/23/2015State v. Jahi D.34,289
06/23/2015State v. Baltes34,115
06/23/2015State v. Box33,845
06/24/2015State v. Frazier34,384
06/24/2015State v. Flores34,444
06/24/2015State v. Noon34,479
06/24/2015State v. Munoz34,161
06/24/2015State v. McDonald34,312
06/24/2015Bank of NY v. Borrego33,988
06/24/2015State v. Sepulveda34,219
06/24/2015State v. Montoya34,505
06/25/2015State v. Garcia34,385
06/25/2015State v. McCarthy34,475
06/25/2015State v. Ostrander34,470
06/25/2015Duncan v. Andrews33,800
06/25/2015State v. Martinez34,147
06/25/2015State v. Lucero34,200
06/25/2015State v. Barela34,230
06/25/2015Wells Fargo Bank v. Montoya34,608
06/25/2015State v. Pena34,539
06/26/2015Edwards v. New Mexico Taxation & Revenue Department34,395
06/26/2015State v. Trahan34,382
06/26/2015Livingston v. Livingston33,906
06/26/2015BAC v. Toloumu34,250
06/29/2015State v. Boynton33,373
06/29/2015State v. Coleman34,088
06/29/2015Doctor's Assoc. v. Carbonell33,997
06/29/2015State v. Martinez34,131
06/30/2015Doyle v. Albuquerque Police Officers' Association34,609
06/30/2015State v. Valle34,517
06/30/2015Nationstar v. Kellen33,923
06/30/2015Haynes v. Presbtyerian Healthcare Services34,489
06/30/2015Scarborough v. C&S Partnership34,483
06/30/2015State v. Padilla32,778
06/30/2015State v. Scenters33,611
06/30/2015Perea v. Paulino34,348
06/30/2015Deutsche Bank National Trust Co. v. Huerta34,337
06/30/2015State v. Gonzales34,329
06/30/2015Brooks v. Diaz-Brooks34,492
06/30/2015State v. Yazzie34,541
07/06/2015Cook v. Wells Fargo31,419
07/09/2015In re Sanchez v. Sanchez33,563
07/09/2015Stinebaugh v. NM Racing Commission32,840
07/13/2015Century Bank v. Praxis Architects, Inc.33,045
07/14/2015State v. Aldaz33,612
07/16/2015State v. Ross33,966
07/16/2015Pooler v. City of Albuquerque34,063
07/16/2015U.S. Bank v. Kesler34,587
07/22/2015State v. Lewis33,357
07/28/2015State v. Cuevas34,374
07/28/2015State v. Barrios34,477
07/28/2015State v. Percy34,197
07/28/2015State v. Baca34,406
07/28/2015Rodriguez v. Valdez34,232
07/30/2015Rozman v. Century Link34,233
07/30/2015State v. Cardenas34,292
08/03/2015State v. Trujillo33,257
08/03/2015State Farm Mutual Automobile Ins. Co. v. Dyea34,533
08/05/2015Serrano v. Los Alamos NTL33,922
08/06/2015State Human Svcs. Dep't v. Lujan34,644
08/06/2015Pacheco v. Pacheco34,646
08/11/2015Becerra v. Allstate33,758
08/13/2015Garcia v. Garcia32,916
08/19/2015State v. Lopez34,166
08/20/2015State ex rel. Human Services Dep't v. Ysco33,933
08/20/2015State v. York33,462
08/24/2015State v. Terrazas34,420
08/25/2015State v. Contreras34,011
08/25/2015State v. Rodriguez34,476
08/26/2015Griego v. NM Workers' Compensation34,238
08/26/2015Childers v. Childers34,311
08/28/2015Fenner v. NM Taxation & Revenue Dep't34,365
09/01/2015State v. Yanke34,474
09/01/2015AFSCME Local 2499 v. Board of County Commissioners34,431
09/02/2015City of Roswell v. Marin G.34,286
09/02/2015State v. Trujeque34,519
09/03/2015Your Credit, Inc. v. Kathleen MacGregor34,606
09/03/2015State v. Lemanski33,846
09/03/2015State v. Contreras32,252
09/08/2015Hamood v. Malik34,720
09/08/2015Citimortgage Inc. v. Jones34,335
09/09/2015State v. Ashley32,974
09/14/2015State v. Mitchell34,573
09/17/2015Estate of Scott v. New34,566
09/17/2015Ortega v. Johnson34,554
09/21/2015State v. Yazzie33,385
09/21/2015Stone v. Smith34,116
09/22/2015State v. East34,389
09/22/2015State v. Hernandez33,525
09/23/2015State ex rel. Village of Los Lunas v. County of Valencia33,903
09/24/2015Berman v. Orduno34,799
09/24/2015Lucero v. Baca34,711
09/24/2015State v. Goodridge34,580
09/28/2015State v. Kirven34,188
09/28/2015Ortiz v. Luse34,634
09/29/2015Petroglyph Mgmt. v. McCorvey34,806
09/29/2015State v. Reyes34,700
09/29/2015Brown v. Matz34,695
09/29/2015State v. Gallegos34,689
09/29/2015Russell v. Russell34,501
09/29/2015State v. Gonzalez34,458
09/29/2015State v. Costelon34,265
09/30/2015State v. Cuevas32,757
09/30/2015State v. Ruiz32,992
09/30/2015State v. Hernandez34,497
10/01/2015State v. Harper34,697
10/01/2015State v. Aranzola32,505
10/01/2015Excel Builders v. Gabaldon32,309
10/01/2015State v. McDaniel31,501
10/01/2015Wolfe v. Fernandez34,425
10/05/2015State v. Shelby34,682
10/06/2015State v. Parra34,577
10/06/2015Schwartz v. New Mexico Medical Board34,412
10/06/2015Green v. Casa Bella Apartments34,393
10/06/2015Sollien v. Sollien34,531
10/07/2015Esparza v. Esparza33,222
10/14/2015State v. Lucero34,360
10/20/2015State v. Astorga32,374
10/21/2015State v. Romero33,376
10/21/2015State v. Sertuche34,579
10/22/2015State v. Axtolis33,664
10/26/2015State v. Mora34,688
10/26/2015State v. Prieto-Lozoya34,666
10/27/2015State v. Abeyta33,485
10/27/2015State v. Archuleta34,699
10/27/2015State v. Wilson34,649
10/27/2015State v. Vannatter34,813
10/28/2015Castro-Montanez v. Milk-N-Atural, LLC34,772
10/28/2015Martinez v. Bar-M Construction34,623
10/29/2015State v. Brown34,733
10/29/2015State v. Paul33,319
11/02/2015Firstenberg v. Leith34,821
11/02/2015Tal Realty, Inc. v. San Angelo Property Servs.33,440
11/03/2015State v. Baca34,390
11/03/2015State v. Garduno34,355
11/04/2015State v. Constelon34,265
11/04/2015State v. Venegas34,565
11/09/2015State v. Terrazas33,241
11/12/2015State v. Kenneth33,281
11/12/2015State v. Henry34,702
11/16/2015Ivey v. Town of Mountainair34,672
11/16/2015State v. Holona34,779
11/16/2015State v. Granados34,736
11/16/2015State v Alanazi34,540
11/16/2015State v. Burge34,679
11/16/2015State v. James34,549
11/16/2015State v. Sandoval33,108
11/17/2015State v. Hart-Omer33,829
11/18/2015Rabo Agrifinance, Inc. v. Terra XXI, Ltd.34,757
11/18/2015State v. Orozco34,665
11/18/2015Owen v. Padilla34,807
11/19/2015State v. Salazar33,417
11/23/2015State v. Depperman33,871
11/23/2015State v. Bejarano34,439
11/23/2015State v. Rivera and State v. Sanchez32,856; 32,857
11/23/2015JPMorgan Chase Bank v. Gomez34,336
11/24/2015State v. Solis34,266
11/24/2015Villalobos v. Villalobos32,973
11/25/2015AFSCME N.M. Council 18 v. Expo N.M.34,430
11/25/2015Gonzales v. Pappadeaux Seafood Kitchen34,767
12/01/2015Cole v. Garcia33,058
12/01/2015State v. Vaughn34,448
12/01/2015State v. Raby33,910
12/02/2015Aguilar v. Filanoksy34,837
12/02/2015Schwartz v. NM Medical Board34,412
12/03/2015State v. Sears34,522
12/03/2015State v. Berres34,729
12/03/2015State v. Abeyta34,705
12/03/2015State v. James34,413
12/07/2015TPC, Inc. v. Hegarty32,165; 32,492
12/07/2015State v. Reed33,426
12/07/2015State v. Hayden34,706
12/08/2015Chavez v. Board of Regents33,785
12/08/2015Falkner v. Albuquerque Police Dept.34,809
12/08/2015State v. Commers34,658
12/08/2015Bell v. Bell32,852
12/09/2015State v. Marquez33,527
12/10/2015State v. Osolio34,652
12/16/2015State v. Gutierrez33,019
12/16/2015State v. Brown32,777
12/16/2015State v. Delgarito34,237
12/16/2015State v. Ancira34,556
12/16/2015State v. Carpenter34,332
12/16/2015Roblez v. Central New Mexico Correctional Facility33,786
12/16/2015State v. Asarisi33,531
12/17/2015State v. Vigil34,815
12/17/2015State v. Romero34,264
12/17/2015State v. Farley34,010
12/17/2015Marchand v. Marchand33,225
12/21/2015State v. Wiggins33,915
12/21/2015State v. Joshua O.34,574
12/22/2015State v. Baca34,133
12/23/2015Levan v. Hayes Trucking33,858
12/23/2015Hernandez v. Children, Youth & Families Dep't33,549
12/23/2015State v. Bayless34,536
12/23/2015State v. Chavez33,095
12/29/2015State v. Hall34,891
12/29/2015State v. Guitierrez34,890
12/29/2015State v. Donovan W.34,595
12/30/2015State v. Vega32,835
12/30/2015Horizon Well Serv., LLC v. PEMCO of NM, LLC33,754
12/30/2015State v. Aguirre34,800
12/30/2015State v. Gabaldon34,770
12/30/2015Childers v. Childers34,752
12/30/2015State v. Lundvall34,715
12/30/2015State v. Navarette34,687
12/30/2015State v. Kane34,660
12/30/2015Citimortgage, Inc. v. Laura Tweed34,870
spacer6