NMCC Banner
spacer1
spacer2
spacer3


New Mexico Court of Appeals – Unreported Memorandum Opinions – 2009
This page contains memorandum opinions of the New Mexico Court of Appeals that were not selected for publication in the New Mexico Reports. Please see Rule 12-405 NMRA for restrictions on the citation of unpublished decisions. Please also note that these electronic decisions may contain computer-generated errors or other deviations from the official paper version filed by the Supreme Court and will not include the filing date. The filing date for each decision can be found in the table below.

Sorting options — The decisions may be sorted by "Filing Date", "Short Title", or "Docket No."
Click on the column name/header — the decisions will sort in descending/ascending order.
Note that the Short Title column contains the full text of the decision in PDF format.

Filing DateShort TitleDocket No.
01/05/2009State v W Droze28,713
01/05/2009State v J Helm28,932
01/05/2009State v A Moreno28,891
01/05/2009R McGrary v AMS Staff Leasing28,867
01/06/2009S Steinmetz v B Steinmetz29,034
01/06/2009Citibank South Dakota v R Giron28,838
01/06/2009State v M Montoya28,833
01/06/2009State v J Heying28,928
01/06/2009L Fernandez v C Council28,935
01/06/2009C Reid v T Powell28,956
01/07/2009State v T Jernigan28,835
01/07/2009State v A Moreno28,805
01/07/2009M Heath v D Hoover28,776
01/07/2009C Fusco v Podiatry Assoc28,671
01/08/2009R Johnson v A Silva29,005
01/12/2009State v H Head28,562
01/12/2009P Salazar v A Baca28,907
01/13/2009C Gallegos v Hacienda Home28,650
01/13/2009State v J Ramirez-Murillo28,933
01/13/2009State v R Begay28,855
01/13/2009State v Y Candelaria27,367
01/13/2009State v R Sims28,771
01/14/2009C Wood v M Cunningham28,582
01/14/2009Santa Fe v Travelers Surety28,944
01/15/2009State v J Nieto28,989
01/15/2009Village of Corrales v D Giron28,991
01/20/2009I Rivera v A Rivera28,006
01/21/2009E Watkins v Fed Home Life28,757
01/21/2009State v J Saenz28,137
01/21/2009State v K Zemariam28,810
01/23/2009J Rogers v M Leatherwood28,993
01/23/2009City of Rio Rancho v J Hardman28,780
01/26/2009E Mayfield v B Tinker28,701
01/26/2009State v D Hadley27,796
01/26/2009Rio Rancho v K Rytter28,979
01/27/2009State v R Burghardt28,957
01/27/2009State v I Montoya28,759
01/27/2009State v G Camacho28,406
01/27/2009State v K Akers27,472
01/27/2009In Matter of C Primero28,916
01/27/2009State v B Todd28,925
01/28/2009State v C Lambert28,688
01/28/2009State v G Cordova28,692
01/29/2009Allstate v B Darley27,533
01/30/2009State v C Carcamo28,818
01/30/2009R-T Lodge v D Weber28,806
01/30/2009State v C Chavarria28,990
01/30/2009PSC of NM v Rancho Vista28,959
01/30/2009State v D Hoffman28,374
02/02/2009State v S Bedah28,892
02/04/2009E Griego v NM Foundation28,899
02/04/2009J Perry v GEO Group28,982
02/04/2009South Valley v H Rodriguez28,961
02/04/2009S Knight v Dardanelles Foundation28,941
02/04/2009Allstate Ins v C Sanchez28,886
02/05/2009State v Joe D28,690
02/09/2009State v G Ardrey27,396
02/09/2009State v D McKinney28,466
02/09/2009J Menke v P Gaddy28,940
02/10/2009State v F Dixon28,913
02/11/2009C Torres v Tax & Rev28,973
02/16/2009State v M Jasso27,507
02/16/2009State v W Johnson28,696
02/16/2009Sunquest v J Lorentzen27,742
02/17/2009State v A Romero27,050
02/17/2009C Crouch v L Sheffield28,958
02/18/2009State v M Quiroz28,752
02/19/2009State v B Madsen29,099
02/19/2009P Mileta v R Jeffryes28,918
02/19/2009HRC v Alliance Communication28,756
02/20/2009D Martinez v D Masseri29,040
02/20/2009State v R McKenzie28,934
02/20/2009E Fox v R Radwanski28,011
02/20/2009State v S Thompson28,853
02/23/2009State v J Carabajal27,302
02/24/2009P Wanco v Dairyland Ins29,009
02/24/2009State v A Turnbull-Phillips27,144
02/24/2009State v D Roanhorse28,884
02/26/2009M Swanson v Archdiocese SFE28,832
02/26/2009State v H Van Es29,015
02/26/2009P Henry v R Myers29,036
02/26/2009M Swanson v Archdiocese SFE28,779
03/03/2009State v C Montano29,072
03/04/2009R Blaney v J Shiver28,922
03/06/2009State v G Uranga28,426
03/10/2009State v L Noyola28,424
03/11/2009State v D Rowlan28,370
03/11/2009State v J Cordova26,523
03/12/2009State v D Phares28,803
03/12/2009State v M Lovato28,910
03/13/2009State v D Tolbert27,326
03/13/2009D Parker v J Parker29,091
03/16/2009H Mora v R Mora28,831
03/16/2009Marina v N Innerbichler29,044
03/16/2009State v S Madrid28,732
03/16/2009State v A Salas29,181
03/17/2009Vanderbilt Mtg v M Wright29,038
03/18/2009M Minjares v M Romero28,992
03/19/2009J Martinez v City of Espanola28,820
03/20/2009J Ray v B Sanchez28,723
03/20/2009Think Back v L Hayes28,786
03/23/2009State v E Aragon26,430
03/24/2009State v M Elvidge28,827
03/25/2009State v A Misquez29,098
03/25/2009State v C Maldonado28,255
03/26/2009State v H Chavez28,612
03/26/2009State v A Gonzales28,483
03/26/2009HSC v E Pino28,710
03/26/2009Sombra Cosmetics v Alivia Lab28,952
03/26/2009Protest of J Mailander28,624
03/26/2009Settlement v T Espinosa27,407
03/26/2009M Reyes v DOT28,502
03/26/2009B Sarracino v UNM Regents28,595
03/26/2009R White v T White28,273
03/26/2009State v D Beaulieu28,830
03/30/2009A Bergman v S Bergman29,073
03/30/2009Estate of D Jaramillo29,209
03/30/2009Golf Course Estates v V Jones29,102
03/31/2009N Lewis v Rio Grande Sun29,184
04/01/2009State v Claryn C29,176
04/01/2009State v B Mackey28,245
04/02/2009S Sederwall v R Virden28,972
04/02/2009Stone Mountain v G Sanchez28,767
04/06/2009State v A Primero28,329
04/06/2009G Romero v Giant28,063
04/06/2009State v Q Ransom28,485
04/09/2009State v B Orona28,814
04/10/2009State v M Berry28,955
04/10/2009State v C Alvarado29,021
04/15/2009State v B Salgado29,020
04/15/2009State v M Lacey28,119
04/15/2009State v J Mora28,844
04/16/2009State v E Duran29,127
04/16/2009W McNeill v Rice Engineering29,207
04/17/2009State v L Jordan28,949
04/20/2009State v P Nez26,811
04/21/2009State v L Boylan28,917
04/21/2009State v J Downs28,490
04/21/2009D Dunagan v G Chavez29,188
04/22/2009State v J Hunt28,753
04/22/2009State v J Carmona27,693
04/23/2009Mortgage Electronic v M Gutierrez29,167
04/23/2009State v L Arthur27,911
04/24/2009A Rodriguez v C Ortega28,947
04/24/2009State v D Williams27,667
04/24/2009I Cedrins v R Shrestha29,242
04/30/2009State v K Judd28,550
05/01/2009D Derringer v J Moore29,135
05/01/2009State v S Chavez29,155
05/01/2009State v C Salles29,222
05/01/2009State v L Corralez28,834
05/01/2009Roswell Clinic v W Seidel MD29,106
05/01/2009City of Aztec v J. Groh29,039
05/04/2009State v F Benally28,999
05/04/2009State v A Ontiveros28,966
05/05/2009City of Belen v J Kerekes29,246
05/05/2009N Dow v J Taylor29,245
05/06/2009M Asprey v J Raabe-Asprey29,216
05/06/2009Cenlar v R Moore26,768
05/07/2009S Drucker v First Nat'l Bank29,107
05/07/2009State v E Torres28,871
05/07/2009R Bianco v Horror One27,887
05/08/2009In re Estate of R Phillips29,249
05/08/2009State v E Honnie28,965
05/08/2009State v R Kirby28,828
05/08/2009State v C Diaz28,703
05/12/2009State v O Marquez28,938
05/12/2009State v S McCorkle29,124
05/12/2009State v R Sanchez28,793
05/14/2009Flagstar Bnk v R Orduno29,352
05/14/2009State v J Gardner27,234
05/14/2009State v R Lara27,166
05/14/2009State v S Johnson27,867
05/18/2009State v E Sena24,156
05/18/2009C Reid v T Powell29,286
05/19/2009State v Anthony C29,027
05/19/2009E Maestas v S Archuleta29,257
05/19/2009W Ferguson v T Gengler29,272
05/19/2009State v R Whiting27,117
05/20/2009State v N Gonzales28,739
05/26/2009Last Will of B Bird29,125
05/26/2009R Virden v S Richesin29,048
05/26/2009B Romero v PB&J29,304
05/26/2009Rapid Temps v L Lamon29,312
05/26/2009R Nieto v UNM28,730
05/27/2009A Perez v Albuquerque28,951
05/27/2009Chase Home v R Giron29,194
05/27/2009A Higgins v J Higgins29,193
05/27/2009Sunrise Bank v M Eckert28,750; 28,939
05/27/2009L Lopresto v E Patterson28,848
05/28/2009J Shepard v K Ozzello28,376
05/28/2009State v J Villegas28,083
05/28/2009Est of McDuffie v R Galusha28,929
05/28/2009S Marquez v L Marquez28,524
05/28/2009State v J Courtney28,300
05/29/2009State v J Suskey29,045
05/29/2009State v J Martinez28,963
06/04/2009State v A Andrade27,715
06/04/2009State v S Blea26,570
06/05/2009State v Robert H29,274
06/05/2009E Montoya v E Montoya28,041
06/08/2009Anderson Hills Homeowners v R Auld28,666
06/08/2009D Bishop v G Johnson28,499
06/08/2009State v W Skinner28,976
06/09/2009State v A Warren29,147
06/10/2009F Muniz v Corrections Dept28,811
06/10/2009State v G Acosta29,139
06/10/2009A Lujan v P Riddle29,180
06/10/2009HSD v C Ryan29,219
06/10/2009State v C Franklin29,384
06/10/2009State v R Ramirez29,185
06/10/2009R Roy v T Tafoya29,250
06/11/2009State v Miguel P29,019
06/11/2009W Dement v R Camp29,287
06/11/2009S Angelo v Home Depot29,171
06/11/2009M Tafoya v Thi of NM at VIDA29,165
06/11/2009State v R Amaro28,919
06/11/2009State v S Salazar28,950
06/11/2009R Swopes v Global Enterprise29,319
06/11/2009State v D Carpenter29,137
06/11/2009M Walborn v Ultimate Masonry29,283
06/11/2009State v E Almager28,912
06/11/2009State v P Myers29,330
06/11/2009State v S Calvillo29,068
06/11/2009J Rivera v Foxworth-Galbraith29,153
06/11/2009State v J Mumau28,930
06/12/2009G&S Waterworks v PRC29,365
06/12/2009Carlsbad v C Tanner29,154
06/12/2009P Niewiadowski v SW Convenience28,800
06/12/2009State v S Medina29,192
06/12/2009State v D Munoz29,119
06/16/2009State v S Osborne27,008
06/16/2009State v K Bennett29,183
06/16/2009D Padilla v B Townsley29,223
06/16/2009A Luna v Anderson Living29,298
06/16/2009Italigree v J Chappelle28,975
06/16/2009State v G Solis-Cordoba29,255
06/17/2009State v J Baldonado29,097
06/17/2009A Esquibel v City of Santa Fe27,548
06/17/2009State v E Smith29,094
06/17/2009M Hynoski v J Harmston29,434
06/17/2009State v F Gutierrez-Salazar29,178
06/18/2009State v C Garcia29,354
06/18/2009State v C Castillo29,256
06/18/2009State v L Vasquez29,233
06/19/2009D Cordova v L Hubbell29,059
06/22/2009State v M Garcia29,399
06/22/2009M Chavira v James Hamilton Const.29,364
06/22/2009State v B Garcia28,465
06/22/2009State v F Dombos28,994
06/25/2009M Valesquez v American Modern27,522
06/26/2009H Houde v G Ferri28,796
06/29/2009State v E Ordunez28,996
06/29/2009State v J Romero29,060
06/29/2009State v W Sanchez28,090
06/29/2009N Lewis v C Padilla29,542
06/29/2009State v C Finch29,350
06/29/2009State v R Valenzuela29,351
06/29/2009State v Garcia29454
06/30/2009State v P Gent28,320
06/30/2009J Quirno v F Wilson29,363
06/30/2009State v M Albarez29,468
06/30/2009State v E Gonzales29,076
06/30/2009State v C Garcia29,413
06/30/2009State v C Benioh27,920
07/01/2009State v R Herrera29,200
07/02/2009M Brown v S Moya29,190
07/02/2009State v M Benavidez29,174
07/07/2009State v T Thyberg27,015
07/08/2009State v D Dixon29,240
07/14/2009B Chatterjee v T King29,473
07/17/2009State v K Jordan29,303
07/23/2009State v B Dorris29,230
07/24/2009J Lucero v A Luna29,323
07/27/2009State v A Cline29,173
07/27/2009State v A Jimenez29,144
07/27/2009State v L Johnson29,320
07/27/2009State v K Shelby29,100
07/27/2009State v E Martinez29,199
07/27/2009State v C Cauffman29,012
07/29/2009State v G Harris28,887
07/29/2009State v V Gonzalez29,297
07/29/2009State v C Duran29,123
07/29/2009State v R Atencio26,707
07/29/2009State v T Portis29,201
07/29/2009Bank of NY v S Dodson29,095
07/29/2009State v M Saucedo29,284
07/29/2009State v J Pinto29,281
07/29/2009Y Gardea v R Gardea29,275
07/30/2009State v D Sprayberry29,277
07/30/2009J Garcia v Guadalupe County29,449
07/30/2009State v S Thompson29,419
07/30/2009DPS v L Jones29,380
07/30/2009State v M Montoya29,464
07/30/2009State v P Sipes29,156
07/30/2009State v B James29,264
07/31/2009National Clinic v C Valdez29,347
07/31/2009State v J Trujillo27,999
07/31/2009State v J Perry28,983
07/31/2009State v J Baca29,368
07/31/2009State v Creighton M29,210
07/31/2009State v D Scott29,417; 29,418
07/31/2009State v F Gutierrez29,004
08/03/2009State v Alvarez29,314
08/06/2009Martinez v Martinez29,562
08/07/2009Oliver v Walck29,366
08/07/2009State v Colwell29,344
08/07/2009State v Trout29,512
08/10/2009City of RR v Duran29,383
08/10/2009State v Guerrero29,373
08/12/2009State v Bryant29,444
08/12/2009State v Terrazas27,613
08/12/2009State v Choyce29,235
08/12/2009Gutierrez v CYFD29,370
08/12/2009State v Gibson29,507
08/12/2009Rio Rancho v Crisuolo29,442
08/12/2009Gonzales v Livingston27,896
08/12/2009State v Henderickson29,349
08/17/2009State v Montoya27,927
08/17/2009State v Tanner27,606
08/18/2009Muniz v Estrada28,902
08/18/2009Progressive Cas Ins Co v Nancy and Martin Vigil28,023
08/18/2009State v Rudolph28,299
08/19/2009New Mexico Bank & Trust v Corliss29,446
08/20/2009State v Muriel28,405
08/20/2009Rodeo v Columbia28,384
08/21/2009Hernandez v Manzanares29,369
08/21/2009State v Robert F28,511
08/21/2009State v Duran29,146
08/24/2009Mesa Finance v Vaughn29,504
08/25/2009State v Boston28,707
08/25/2009State v Vasquez27,763
08/26/2009Lucero v Waxford29,273
08/26/2009State v Manning27,756
08/26/2009Spengler v Spengler28,927
08/27/2009State v Ruiz29,381
08/27/2009Anaya v Owens29,437
08/27/2009Rancho Riodoso v Lincoln Co29,439
08/27/2009Warren v Boothby29,290
08/28/2009Lea County v Jasperse29,552
08/28/2009Miller v Thi NM at Alameda29,459
08/28/2009State v Benally29,293
08/28/2009Anaya v Rinker29,414
08/28/2009State v Mosimann29,403
08/31/2009In re Estate of C de Baca27,069; 27164
08/31/2009Stevens Real Estate v Hunter's Draw29,498
09/01/2009Jernigan v Gonzales27,924
09/01/2009Lewis v Sena29,607
09/02/2009Zuniga v Zuniga29,161
09/02/2009Corliss v Eastern29,152
09/02/2009Galusha v Romero29,544
09/02/2009State v Vigil29,420
09/03/2009Exclusive Homes v Montoya27,664
09/03/2009State v Moesch28,362
09/03/2009Coyne v Olson29,579
09/04/2009State v Roybal29,289
09/04/2009State v Carbajal28,640
09/04/2009State v Jim29,483
09/04/2009Espalin v Espalin29,474
09/08/2009Salcido v Baca-Dory29,577
09/08/2009Roberts v Martinez29,578
09/08/2009Remondini v JFF Inc29,252
09/09/2009Reyes v DOT28,502
09/09/2009State v Crisantos G29,392
09/09/2009State v Turrietta29,508
09/09/2009State v Romero29,536
09/10/2009Kemper v Leslie28,923
09/11/2009Salness v Salness28,843
09/14/2009State v Osby29,571
09/14/2009State v Solis29,407
09/14/2009State v Bedaw29,584
09/15/2009Romero v Alires29,527
09/16/2009State v Alvarez29,637
09/16/2009State v Stone29,673
09/16/2009City of Artesia v Hackett29,592
09/17/2009State v Aagesen29,313
09/18/2009Herrera v Eberline Services28,577
09/21/2009State v J Castillo29,116
09/21/2009State v Rodriguez29,229
09/21/2009State v Wiseheart29,472
09/21/2009State v Andrez27400
09/22/2009State v Holland29,337
09/22/2009Hymans v Safeco Ins29,618
09/22/2009State v Garrett29,355
09/22/2009Sedillo v Sedillo28,971
09/23/2009In RE Cruz-Calderon29,545
09/23/2009Gallegos v Trujillo29,645
09/23/2009State v Jonathon D27,552
09/28/2009State v Pacheco29,056
09/28/2009State v Quiroz29,428
09/28/2009State v Boze29,168
09/30/2009State v Rueda29,145
10/01/2009State v Reid29,172
10/02/2009State v Calhoun29,422
10/05/2009State v Puliti29,509
10/05/2009State v Melendez27,758
10/05/2009Lewis v Human Services Dept.29,582
10/06/2009State v Jim29,483
10/06/2009State v Episcopo29,328
10/06/2009State v Morgan29,478
10/07/2009State v Anthony L29,206
10/08/2009In re Est. of Marietta29,182
10/13/2009State v Haskins26,525
10/13/2009State v Muniz29,616
10/13/2009State v Blanco27,153
10/14/2009Cordova v Cordova28,208
10/19/2009Martinez v Ortiz29,662
10/19/2009Smith v American Pride Home29,598
10/19/2009Abeyta v Perea29,560
10/19/2009Ortega v Carlsbad Municipal School29,533
10/19/2009Davidson v Kurucz29,586
10/20/2009Salas v Express Scripts29,495
10/20/2009State v Harvey29,563
10/20/2009State v Valero29,158
10/20/2009Barton v Barton29,501
10/20/2009State v Nanney29,593
10/20/2009State v Rodriguez29,345
10/23/2009State v Snider28,257
10/26/2009Revilla v Revilla29,636
10/26/2009State v Alderete28,325
10/27/2009Armijo v Lovelace Sandia Health29,482
10/27/2009State v Borunda28,372
10/29/2009Jordan v Allstate28,638
11/02/2009State v Johnson29,359
11/02/2009State v Judd29,460
11/02/2009State v Emanuel B29,594
11/03/2009Hobbs v Galavez29,487
11/03/2009State v Alex29,391
11/03/2009City of Alamogordo v NM State Engineer28,643
11/04/2009State v Trujillo27,291
11/05/2009State v Flores27,647
11/05/2009State v Adrian N28,623
11/06/2009State v Patrick29,506
11/09/2009State v Smith28,402
11/10/2009Smith v ENMRSH28,449
11/10/2009Zamora v Excel Hospitality29,775
11/12/2009State v Munoz28,327
11/13/2009Bradley v Lovelace27,936
11/16/2009State v Herrera29,697
11/16/2009Conway v Conway28,351
11/16/2009Van Den Brink v Van Den Brink29,764
11/16/2009Yazzie v Chava28,375
11/16/2009State v Key29,792
11/17/2009State v Beyale29,639
11/17/2009Mitchell-Carr v Wallace29,706
11/18/2009State v Sewell26,742
11/18/2009Rael v Presbyterian Healthcare Services29,600
11/18/2009City of Farmington v Dickerson29,540
11/19/2009Kittell v Kittell29,693
11/19/2009Muse v Muse29,696
11/19/2009Golden v Golden29,549
11/19/2009State v Reyes29,630
11/19/2009City of Roswell v Forrest29,649
11/23/2009Scorza v Hankins29,729
11/23/2009State v Lopez-Esquivel29,558
11/24/2009State v Begaye28,348
11/24/2009State v Martinez29,451
11/24/2009Brewer v Niemyjski29,688
11/24/2009Hiner v S. Farm Bureau28,484
11/24/2009Baca v NM Dept of Workforce Solutions29,836
11/25/2009State v Skippings28,324
11/25/2009Rodriguez v Wal-mart29,518
11/25/2009State v Peterson28,874
11/25/2009State v Lopez29,475
11/25/2009State v Martinez29,497
11/25/2009State v Haney29,638
11/25/2009Mambo v Best29,610
11/25/2009State v Pacheco28,568
12/02/2009Davis v. Davis29,738
12/02/2009Ferguson v. Ferguson29,550
12/02/2009Sysco Food Servs. v. RMT Enters29,626
12/02/2009Nat'l City Bank v. Morrow29,658
12/03/2009State v. Wylie29,694
12/03/2009Mitchell v. Wallace29,754
12/03/2009Grygorwicz v. Trujillo29,770
12/04/2009State v. Lopez29,259; 29,302
12/07/2009State v. Tapia29,573
12/07/2009State v. Sanchez29,737
12/09/2009State v. Henry29,668
12/09/2009State v. Vasquez29,602
12/09/2009Carril v. Black29,612
12/09/2009Carlson v. Carlson29,798
12/09/2009Lopez v. NM Construction29,531
12/09/2009State v. Tannehill29,783
12/09/2009State v. Zertuche29,682
12/09/2009State v. Martinez29,648
12/09/2009State v. Benallie29,650
12/09/2009State v. Multine29,516
12/10/2009Newbury v. Valencia29,695
12/10/2009Johnson & Danley v. State29,575
12/10/2009Imboden v. Imboden29,677
12/10/2009Delgado v. Delgado28,936
12/11/2009Ogden v. Torres29,746
12/11/2009Toser v. Whitty29,305
12/14/2009State v. Henry28,507
12/14/2009State v. Bryant29,386
12/14/2009State v. Romero29,503
12/16/2009Chase v. Giron29,194
12/16/2009Target Nat'l Bank v. Ramirez29,831
12/16/2009Griego v. Griego29,572
12/16/2009State v. Sanchez28,722
12/21/2009Baca v. WW Construction29,665
12/21/2009Salazar v. Las Vegas Med Ctr29,631
12/21/2009Baca v. Karsten Homes29,727
12/21/2009State v. Serna29,655
12/21/2009State v. Spencer28,134
12/21/2009State v. San Juan29,675
12/21/2009Mitchell v. Wallace29,700
12/21/2009Tafoya v. Tafoya29,784
12/22/2009State v. Parkman29,646
12/22/2009Rivera v. Healthsouth Rehab29,621
12/22/2009Poncho v. Everest Group29,614
12/23/2009State v. Garley28,760
12/23/2009Kiewit NM v. Day29,796
12/23/2009Sands v. Green29,837
12/28/2009State v. Ketelson29,876
12/29/2009In the Matter of Beverly Kutzner In Re J. Robert Beauvais29,651
12/29/2009Clovis v. Gamez29,177
12/30/2009NM Public School Insurance Authority v. Newt & Butch's Roofing29,709
spacer6