NMCC Banner
spacer1
spacer2
spacer3

New Mexico Court of Appeals — Prior Year Opinions
To search prior years of published opinions from the Supreme Court and New Mexico Court of Appeals, click here.

Sorting options — The opinions may be sorted by "Filing Date", "Short Title", "Opinion Number", or "Docket No."
Click on the column name/header — the opinions will sort in descending/ascending order. Note that the
Short Title column contains the full text of the official final version of an opinion in PDF format.

Filing DateShort TitleOpinion NumberDocket No.
06/03/2008Dell Catalog Sales, L.P. v. N.M. Taxation And Revenue Dept.2009-NMCA-00126,843
11/03/2008State v. Ochoa2009-NMCA-00224,720
11/13/2008Muse v. Muse2009-NMCA-00327,177; 27,281; 27,509; 27,944
09/24/2008State of N.M. ex rel State Engineer v. Commissioner of Public Lands2009-NMCA-00427,654
10/30/2008Carlsbad Hotel Associates, LLC v. Patterson-UTI Drilling Co.2009-NMCA-00527,922
12/01/2008Pipkin v. Daniel2009-NMCA-00628,212
10/29/2008Debbie L. v. Galadriel R.2009-NMCA-00727,101
11/05/2008State v. Hayes2009-NMCA-00828,055
12/15/2008Montano v. N.M. Real Estate Appraiser's Bd.2009-NMCA-00927,374
12/15/2008State v. Tran2009-NMCA-01027,967
11/14/2008Martinez v. Cornejo2009-NMCA-01127,382; 27,383
12/09/2008State v. Romero2009-NMCA-01227,236
12/30/2008Budget Rent-a-Car Systems, Inc., v. Bridgestone2009-NMCA-01327,877
10/21/2008State v. Billington2009-NMCA-01426,984
10/24/2008Woodhull v. Meinel2009-NMCA-01527,959
10/20/2008Pena Blanca Partnership v. San Jose Community Ditch2009-NMCA-01628,005
01/21/2009Chapel v. Nevitt2009-NMCA-01727,127
09/16/2008Lee v. Catron2009-NMCA-01828,590
10/30/2008Kinder Morgan CO2 Co v. NM Taxation & Revenue Dept.2009-NMCA-01927,734
12/18/2008State v. O’Neal2009-NMCA-02027,751
12/29/2008State v. Phillips2009-NMCA-02127,019
11/18/2008Romero v. Philip Morris, Inc.2009-NMCA-02226,993
12/08/2008State v. Villegas2009-NMCA-02327,993
12/09/2008State v. Vance2009-NMCA-02427,048
02/02/2009State of N.M. ex rel CYFD v. John R.2009-NMCA-02527,880; 27,985
02/02/2009Galassi v. Galassi2009-NMCA-02627,784
02/03/2009State v. Dylan J.2009-NMCA-02726,131; 26,562
12/18/2008State v. Smith2009-NMCA-02827,704
02/09/2009Montoya v. Medina2009-NMCA-02927,386
12/29/2008State v. Leyba2009-NMCA-03027,597
01/08/2009State v. Dietrich2009-NMCA-03125,220
02/16/2009State of N.M. ex rel CYFD v. Johnny S., Sr.2009-NMCA-03228,852
02/18/2009Santa Fe Estates, Inc. v. Concerned Residents of SF North, Inc.2009-NMCA-03327,856
01/12/2009State v. Casillas2009-NMCA-03427,253
01/12/2009Gomez v. Chavarria2009-NMCA-03528,072; 28,073
01/26/2009State v. Guthrie2009-NMCA-03627,022
02/17/2009Guest v. Allstate Insurance Co.2009-NMCA-03727,253
03/02/2009State v. Enlow2009-NMCA-03827,951
03/13/2009State of N.M. ex rel CYFD v. Benjamin O.2009-NMCA-03928,790
01/30/2009State v. Yazzie2009-NMCA-04028,813
02/26/2009Ortiz v. Overland Express2009-NMCA-04128,135
03/03/2009Eisert v. Archdiocese of Santa Fe2009-NMCA-04227,728
03/16/2009Karpien v. Karpien2009-NMCA-04328,060
03/17/2009State v. Lopez2009-NMCA-04427,078
03/23/2009San Pedro Neighborhood Assn. v. SF County BCC2009-NMCA-04527,907
03/25/2009Zabolzadeh v. Zabolzadeh2009-NMCA-04628,589
03/25/2009Romero v. Parker2009-NMCA-04727,027
03/26/2009Mason Family Trust v. DeVaney2009-NMCA-04828,554
03/16/2009State v. Rivera2009-NMCA-04925,798
04/01/2009Zarr v. Washington Tru Solutions, LLC2009-NMCA-05027,553
03/13/2009Akins v. United Steel Workers of America2009-NMCA-05127,132
04/07/2009State v. Perry2009-NMCA-05226,842
04/07/2009State v. Gipson2009-NMCA-05328,531
02/11/2009State of NM ex rel CYFD v. Lance K.2009-NMCA-05426,632
03/13/2009State v. Balenquah2009-NMCA-05526,678
05/05/2009Holguin v. Tsay Corporation2009-NMCA-05628,777
05/07/2009City of Farmington v. The Daily Times2009-NMCA-05727,858
05/12/2009State of NM ex rel CYFD v. Marlene C.2009-NMCA-05828,352
04/28/2009Romero v. Giant Stop-N-Go of NM, Inc.2009-NMCA-05928,063
04/13/2009State v. Mendez2009-NMCA-06028,261
05/14/2009State v. Delgado2009-NMCA-06127,192
05/14/2009Stansell v. NM Lottery2009-NMCA-06228,241; 28,505
05/27/2009Carter v. NM Human Services Dept.2009-NMCA-06327,943
05/07/2009State v. Smile2009-NMCA-06427,338
05/07/2009Alb. Commons Partnership v. Alb. City Council2009-NMCA-06524,026; 24,027; 24,042; 24,425
06/10/2009Griffin v. Penn2009-NMCA-06627,786
06/25/2009State v. Davis2009-NMCA-06726,573
03/23/2009State v. Jackson2009-NMCA-06828,107
03/30/2009Williams v. Farmers Insurance Co.2009-NMCA-06928,220
04/21/2009Pacheco v. Cohen2009-NMCA-07028,469
04/21/2009State v. LaCouture2009-NMCA-07127,357
05/06/2009Edmonds v. Martinez2009-NMCA-07228,029
06/17/2009State v. Gamlen2009-NMCA-07328,215
06/18/2009State v. Palacio2009-NMCA-07428,028
05/11/2009State v. Lee2009-NMCA-07527,402
05/11/2009State v. Thompson2009-NMCA-07628,358
05/11/2009State v. Pickett2009-NMCA-07727,938
05/29/2009Kilgore v. Fuji Heavy Industries, Ltd.2009-NMCA-07827,470
06/12/2009State v. Soliz2009-NMCA-07928,018
06/29/2009Skeen v. Boyles2009-NMCA-08027,910; 28,318
06/09/2009City of Albuquerque v. BPLW Architects & Engineers, Inc.2009-NMCA-08127,837
06/30/2009Homer F. and Joyce F. v. Jeremiah E.2009-NMCA-08228,694
06/30/2009Vives v. Verzino2009-NMCA-08328,480
06/30/2009Papatheofanis v. Allen2009-NMCA-08427,535
05/05/2009State v. Clements2009-NMCA-08526,953
06/04/2009State v. Atcitty2009-NMCA-08627,189; 27,333; 27,940
04/24/2009Martinez v. Cities of Gold Casino2009-NMCA-08728,762
05/08/2009N.M. Gamefowl Assn., Inc. v. State of NM ex rel Gary King2009-NMCA-08828,388
05/28/2009State v. Chavez2009-NMCA-08928,948
06/02/2009State v. Rodriguez2009-NMCA-09027,437
06/03/2009State v. Reyes2009-NMCA-09126,593
08/13/2009State v. Ortiz2009-NMCA-09227,544
05/15/2009Chairez v. James Hamilton Construction Co.2009-NMCA-09327,581; 28,201
05/26/2009State of NM ex rel CYFD v. Cosme V.2009-NMCA-09428,328
07/21/2009Sandoval v. Baker Hughes Oilfield Operations, Inc.2009-NMCA-09528,266
06/16/2009State v. Hernandez2009-NMCA-09628,265
06/23/2009Intl. Assn. of Firefighters v. City of Carlsbad2009-NMCA-09728,189
06/25/2009State v. Solano2009-NMCA-09828,166
06/30/2009State v. Diggs2009-NMCA-09927,812
07/09/2009Arias v. Phoenix Indemnity Ins. Co.2009-NMCA-10028,282
07/28/2009Waterfall Community Water Users Assn. v. NM State Engineer2009-NMCA-10128,049
07/30/2009State v. Aragon2009-NMCA-10227,615
06/30/2009Pruyn v. Lam2009-NMCA-10328,103
07/30/2009State v. Rudy B.2009-NMCA-10427,589
07/31/2009Crespin v. Albuquerque Baseball Club, LLC2009-NMCA-10527,864
08/10/2009Gutierrez v. Intel Corporation2009-NMCA-10628,472; 28,678
06/30/2009State v. Garcia2009-NMCA-10727,939
07/01/2009State v. Maez2009-NMCA-10827,528
08/14/2009Gonzales v. State of New Mexico PERA2009-NMCA-10928,108; 28,109
08/25/2009Kirkpatrick v. Santa Fe County BCC2009-NMCA-11027,842
06/04/2009State v. Brusuelas2009-NMCA-11127,107
06/23/2009State v. Lopez2009-NMCA-11227,862
08/19/2009OS Farms, Inc. v. NM American Water Co., Inc.2009-NMCA-11328,353
08/24/2009Roybal v. Lujan de la Fuente2009-NMCA-11427,872
08/26/2009State v. Quintana2009-NMCA-11527,859
06/25/2009Guzman v. Laguna Development Corp.2009-NMCA-11627,827
07/23/2009Moongate Water Co., Inc. v. City of Las Cruces2009-NMCA-11726,386
07/27/2009Clark v. Sims2009-NMCA-11827,782
08/14/2009Keith v. Manorcare, Inc.2009-NMCA-11928,008
08/28/2009Thompson v. Dehne2009-NMCA-12027,650
09/03/2009Hunnicutt v. Sewell2009-NMCA-12128,343
06/18/2009Dickens v. Laurel Healthcare, LLC2009-NMCA-12229,239
08/13/2009Rael v. Page2009-NMCA-12327,332
08/28/2009State v. Jacquez2009-NMCA-12428,419
09/08/2009Nelson v. Homier Distributing Co., Inc.2009-NMCA-12527,543
09/11/2009Oldham v. Oldham2009-NMCA-12628,493
08/20/2009State v. Lopez2009-NMCA-12727,891
09/17/2009State v. Trujillo2009-NMCA-12828,412
10/07/2009Vescio v. Wolf2009-NMCA-12927,893
10/16/2009State v. Montano2009-NMCA-13028,821
08/10/2009Branch v. Chamisa Dev. Corp., Ltd.2009-NMCA-13128,367
09/17/2009State v. Rivera2009-NMCA-13227,168
spacer6